Top NY Injury Law Firms
Fair Rate Funding provides fast, easy legal funding to plaintiffs and attorneys as a means to endure a sometimes long, drawn out litigation process. We’ve been in business since 2007 and over that time, have seen thousands of cases come to conclusion. That experience, and because we are legal professionals ourselves, gives us a unique insight into the personal injury game. In this post, we examine the top 5 personal injury law firms in New York.
Ranking is based upon a variety of factors, including our own experiences dealing with these firms. Other factors include our own legal experience, opinions of other professionals similarly situated in the New York legal space, recent large verdicts and settlements and a host of other factors.
Our decision-making process is proprietary. However, we sometimes change our ratings over time. You can view these changes as they become available.
So, here are the top 5 personal injury law firms in New York.
Top NY Personal Injury Law Firm # 1
Gair, Gair, Conason, Rubinowitz, Bloom, Hershenhorn, Steigman & Mackauf
New York City

The firm was founded in 1919 in New York City by Harry A. Gair, a respected trial attorney. Today, the firm is still based in Manhattan and features some of the finest personal injury attorneys in the United States. Presently, the firm is run by managing partner, Ben Rubinowitz, ranked Number 1 of all attorneys in New York by Super Lawyers, which recognizes the top attorneys nationwide.
This boutique law firm focuses their resources on a select few personal injury matters (approximately 80-100 per year). The value of this approach reveals itself as you look at their results. The firm routinely yields multi-million dollar recoveries and even their website claims they’ve secured almost $2 billion over the years.
Their website explains, “. . . because we only accept a select few cases, we are able to spend more resources than other firms to secure the most knowledgeable experts and to get the best results for our clients.” And that appears to be true.
For example, in a lawsuit filed in state Supreme Court in January 2020 and tried before Judge Paul Marx in state Supreme Court in Westchester County, a jury awarded $120 million — reportedly the largest malpractice verdict in Westchester County history — for damages suffered after Westchester Medical Center doctors delayed treatment for a stroke.
These types of verdicts may not be common. What is common is the professionalism in which Gair, Gair, Conason handles its business. For these reasons, the firm makes #1 on our list.
New York Personal Injury Law Firm #2
Block, O’Toole & Murphy
New York City
Founded by Jeffrey A. Block in 1989, Block, O’Toole & Murphy is a premier personal injury law firm serving New York and the surrounding areas. They employ 22 attorneys in the practice, making this a large plaintiffs’ firm by most measures.
According to their website, thirteen (13) of the firm’s attorneys are regarded as Super Lawyers, and the three (3) managing partners are recognized nationally by Best Lawyers®, another attorney ranking organization. Regardless of rankings, Block, O’Toole & Murphy are talented, diligent attorneys who zealously represent their client’s interests. Their results speak for themselves.
For example in 2019, a jury awarded a Brooklyn cyclist $110,000,000 in a lawsuit which alleged negligence against the NYC Transit Authority when a beam fell upon him, severing his spine. At the time, it was believed to be the largest non-medical malpractice verdict to date. Although the amount was later reduced on appeal, the result is indicative of the work and dedication the Block, O’Toole & Murphy firm offers its clients.
A quick review of the Google Reviews shows the appreciation and positive experiences their clients received. One client reviewed:
“Block, O’Toole and Murphy exceeded my expectations in every way possible. The level of professionalism is unwavering and still very human at their core. I could not be more pleased with the experience I have had. I would hire them again and I would recommend them to anyone in need of legal assistance.”
Positive results, reviews and other factors such as their reputation throughout the State Bar place Block, O’Toole & Murphy at #2 on our list of top 5 personal injury law firms in New York.
Top New York PI Law Firm #3
The Flomenhaft Law Firm, PLLC
The Flomenhaft Law Firm’s practice exists in a niche area of the law, but that doesn’t preclude its mention on our top 5 injury law firms in New York. Mr. Flomenhaft is a graduate of Hofstra University and Boston University School of Law. His practice involves trying cases for victims of traumatic brain injuries and severe chronic pain.
Flomenhaft is nationally recognized as an expert in spinal neurology and the legal challenges these allegations present in the courtroom. His success speaks for itself, having won landmark evidentiary rulings from New York state courts establishing the scientific validity of Diffusion Tensor Imaging (DTI), which shows white matter/axonal brain damage frequently visible in accident victims. Courts also recognize Quantitative Electroencephalography (qEEG) studies, which show deterioration in the brain’s electrical activity following traumatic brain injury. Also through the efforts of the Flomenhaft Law Firm, Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI), showing brain changes demonstrating severe pain, is also admissible evidence.
The Flomenhaft Law Firm generates the bulk of its clients from referrals from other lawyers who may simply not have the requisite expertise to try TBI cases in the same manner in which the Flomenhaft Firm can. This signifies the trust attorneys possess for the firm’s expertise. Most referring attorneys are trial lawyers themselves. Yet they refer their TBI cases to the Flomenhaft Firm because of their expertise, professionalism and results.
For these reasons, the Flomenhaft Law Firm makes our list.
Top New York Personal Injury Firm #4
Patrick Owen Law
Middletown, New York

Located about an hour and a half outside of Manhattan, personal injury attorney Patrick S. Owen is a premier upstate personal injury lawyer. The Firm’s lawyers have decades of personal injury law experience and this experience serves their clients well. The firm represents injured plaintiffs whose conditions result from car and motorcycle accidents, construction-related accidents, pedestrian accidents, slip and falls, wrongful death, and accidents due to poor road design or maintenance.
As a small firm, Patrick Owen Law are extremely attentive to their clients’ needs and deliver representation with a personal approach. Their clients receive personalized attention to detail, even with the most complex legal matters. Zealous representation has become the norm at the Firm and is expected from clients residing at or near Orange, Dutchess, Sullivan, and Ulster Counties. Patrick Owen Law also accepts referrals from other lawyers – a testament to their reputation in the legal community. The Firm also has a proven track record, at times being able to garner millions of dollars in settlement money for individual clients.
Patrick Owen Law reviews tell the story. One client writes:
Patrick, Veronica and Christian handled my account with professionalism and courtesy I will always be grateful for the work that was done. All phone calls and emails are answered promptly and I was totally confident with the way everything was handled.
For their experience, personal attentiveness and glowing reviews, the Patrick Owen Firm makes our list of top personal injury law firms in New York.
#5 Personal Injury Law Firm in New York
The Barnes Firm
Buffalo, New York
With over 40 attorneys nationwide, the Barnes Firm began in Buffalo, New York and the surrounding area. Thousands of plaintiffs have trusted The Barnes Firm with their accident claims.
Originally part of the Cellino and Barnes injury firm, nationally known for their advertising jingles, the firm recently split and the Barnes Firm became its own practice. Yet the experience and expertise garnered from those years of representing injured parties still remains – to the benefit of their clients.
The Barnes Firm has a track record of success, and the team has helped accident victims and their families recover millions of dollars. In fact, the Firm boasts it’s secured over $2.5 billion for their clients over the years.
The Barnes Firm generally receives positive reviews highlighting their professionalism, dedication, and ability to achieve favorable outcomes for clients. Many reviewers praise specific attorneys and their responsiveness in their write-ups.
The sheer volume of their case involvement makes the Barnes Firm a solid participant in this listing of the top 5 personal injury firms in New York.
Personal Injury Attorney Choice, Lawsuit Loans and Other Considerations
Choosing a New York personal injury law firm to handle your case can require some investigation and research. Ultimately, plaintiffs want results. No matter where you reside, plaintiffs should interview multiple lawyers to get the best fit. Attorneys are people and can vibe with clients differently. Although it may take some time, meeting with multiple personal injury attorneys can be well worth the effort.
Fair Rate Funding is a plaintiff’s advocate firm which financially assists plaintiffs while their cases are pending. Because most states prohibit attorneys from advancing money to their clients, litigants in these regions can turn to “lawsuit loans” to help them endure a sometimes long process. Our goal is to help plaintiffs get the compensation they deserve. We hope this list of top 5 personal injury law firms in New York is helpful.
Consider Fair Rate Funding if you need lawsuit funding prior to settlement. Our rates are the best in the business.
Why Choose Fair Rate Funding
You obviously have a choice in who you use for legal funding. We offer:
- Simple and Easy Process – Approval only on the strength of your case.
- Risk – Free Proposition – Only repay if you win your case.
- Rapid Approval and Funding – Approvals often within 24 hrs.
- Up Front Pricing – Absolutely no hidden fees.
Many lawsuit loan alternatives exist, yet some of their shortcomings are substantial. If you are a plaintiff and need immediate cash you should explore all your options. If you want to learn more about lawsuit loans and other alternatives, please contact us online or give us a call.
When you reach out, a live representative will help you and answer all your questions. At Fair Rate Funding, we want our clients to be well informed. That is why we write these articles. If you have any questions, give us a call today. We are here to help and are at your service.
Thank you for your interest in Fair Rate Funding.
